Anglo-Turkish Society

Erik Blackthorne-O’Barr online lecture: ‘Epidemiologies: The Discourse of Disease in Victorian Britain and Late Ottoman Istanbul’, 16 February 2021 - flyer:

1- You are currently a doctoral student at MESAAS department at Columbia University focusing on Ottoman depictions of Iran. This field seems a lot less covered by other researchers where the focus seems to be more geared to Ottoman diplomatic relations history with Western powers. What are your chief sources of information when dealing with the notion of ‘diplomatic perception’ and does the study also look at the other end of this long-relationship, how this was viewed by the various Iranian dynasties?

Thank you so much for an excellent question. You are absolutely correct that historically, the focus of Ottoman studies regarding the period that I study – the late nineteenth-century – has overwhelmingly been on the Ottoman relationship to Europe, connected naturally with the broader analytics of Westernization, modernization, colonialism and so forth. Although there is indeed much excellent scholarship on the period of Ottoman-Safavid rivalry and competition, during the supposed “golden age” of both empires, after the Safavid collapse it is almost as if Iran drops out of the historiography – studies of Ottoman-Zand or Ottoman-Qajar relations are only recently starting to move from a niche interest into becoming a major subfield in their own right, particularly with the transcription and publication of a great deal of diplomatic correspondence. Yet the nineteenth-century is actually one of the most interesting periods for studying the entanglements between these two states, because in addition to this diplomatic correspondence, we also have a wonderful proliferation of travelogues, newspapers, royal visits, photographs, sanitary and quarantine regulations, and the wealth of archival material related to the delineation of the border and the institution of new regimes of citizenship between the two states. The nineteenth-century also witnesses Istanbul becoming one of the preeminent sites of Iranian diasporic intellectual and political activity, and we can see how ideas and concepts were moving between Ottoman reformers and Iranian dissidents, and how political thought was really being shaped by the cosmopolitan environment of the nineteenth-century metropolis. For this reason, the study of this relationship actually informs us about a lot of the political developments of that century, which would later come to really shape the structure of the Turkish Republic and modern Iran.

2- It could be said that epidemics and famines bring out perhaps the best and worse aspect in the governance and reactions in societies. Do you focus on these calamities to study not so much the epidemic and its consequences but to peer into the Ottoman society mentalities with all its inherent complexity regarding the different millets and foreigners also residing in 19th century Istanbul?

Yes, I think that’s exactly right. I have immense respect for the historians of disease and epidemics, including those who really go deeply into collaboration with geneticists, epidemiologists and biologists and model an interdisciplinary approach to these historical events. My own basis is fundamentally in the techniques and practices of cultural and social history, and so I approach this topic from that aspect – looking not so much at the outbreak itself but at how these events came to act as metaphors and symbols which shaped (and, of course, continue to shape) social life. So, for instance, I am interested in what the theorist Pheng Cheah calls the “organismic metaphor,” which really takes off in the nineteenth-century, and which takes the biological form as the archetype for abstractions like society, government, language, the mind, the environment, and so forth, and thinks in terms of dichotomies like health, disease, contamination, and purification. How did the social experience of the great nineteenth-century epidemics – above all, cholera – come to radically restructure realms of thought which at first glance seem totally unrelated to the facts of the disease itself? Obviously, these outbreaks reveal really important things about the mentalities and complexities of the Ottoman context, but as parts of global events, they also speak to much broader changes in thought.

3- You seem to point that the threat of an anticipated health crisis is sometimes a bigger challenge to the ruling authority than dealing with a crisis and you refer to the cholera outbreak of 1871 in Istanbul as a case point where it produced no great social changes or ‘new truths’. The British community were effectively made to choose two divergent paths of either following Ottoman sanitary regulations backed by a prominent local British physician or British diplomatic service recommendations. Does this dichotomy also tell us much about general British foreign policy regarding expatriate residents control in a ‘colonial mindset’ more than science based analysis of cholera at the time?

I think it serves to remind us of the real ambiguity of cholera during this time, and the institutional inertia and vested interests which made it difficult for science to operate in an “ideal” manner with regard to it. As Christopher Hamlin notes in his excellent study of cholera, the writings of Anglo-Indian doctors on the disease during the outbreak of the first cholera pandemic were marked by extreme thoroughness and careful experimentation, but these works were often ignored by continental European physicians as frontier medicine rather than real science; later, Anglo-Indian doctors vehemently opposed contagionist theory as the writings of theoreticians who were unaware of the endemic conditions in India (despite the evidence provided by John Snow, among others). Erwin Ackerknecht has noted that contagionism, with its quarantines and top-down sanitary measures, came to be associated with Mediterranean autocratic governments, and anti-contagionism with liberal democracy; in such a situation, who were the British residents of Istanbul to follow? As we have seen with our current pandemic, even the most basic medical practices can be quite easily politicized and made into markers of identity, colonial or otherwise. But, of course, this provided quite a contrast with the language of the urban press, which tried to speak in universal terms for a generalized public audience.

4- Was Istanbul during the latter part of the 19th century a centre of scientific discourse on a par with European capitals and more to the point were the Sultans and his advisors fully informed of advances in knowledge in disease and epidemics?

This is an interesting question with two, interrelated answers. In the first case, of course, Istanbul during the 1870s, and especially earlier, did not really have any facilities that were devoted to scientific research as such – important modern institutions for medical science in the city, such as the Tıbbhane-i Âmire, the Darülfünun, or the Bakteriyolojihane-i Şahane (after 1894) were primarily devoted to teaching and treatment rather than experimental research. In that sense, there were no centers of scientific research in the manner of the Hygienic Laboratory in Washington or the Institut Pasteur in Paris. However, when we think about the critical importance of Istanbul’s medical institutions (sanitary boards, quarantine facilities, testing centers, hospitals, and medical journals) within the global network of epidemic research and disease control, Istanbul clearly appears as a central node within a broader, interdependent system. Perhaps I can answer the second point in this regard: the development of Istanbul’s medical institutions within the realm of civil society, as well as in bureaucratic institutions with a degree of autonomy from the palace, made the actual knowledge of the Sultan and the court physicians considerably less important to the operation of Ottoman medicine. Although Sultans like Abdülaziz and Abdülhamid II were familiar with sanitary regulations in their political aspects, their particular opinions and personal patronage were less critical to the actual functioning of the system than they would have been before the Tanzimat era. We might contrast this to some degree with Iran, where the more personal power of the shah and his court officials, and the relative weakness of medical institutions, meant that figures like the court physicians Jakob Eduard Polak and Joseph Désiré Tholozan had considerably more influence on Qajar medical policy.

5- You paint a picture of the Ottoman capital at the time dotted with European doctors and physicians, attached to the palace, embassies, consulates and no doubt their mission hospitals. Were there any trained doctors from the Turkish community or their own medical training school, so in a way also as a means to push-back to the notion that all scientific wisdom comes from the ‘enlightened West’?

Of course! By 1870, we already have decades of Turkish and Muslim doctors educated in modern medical institutions, as well as a vast community of doctors who utilized elements of humoral medicine in the older tradition alongside 19th-century pharmacology and more contemporary methods of diagnosis. The official medical establishment was very cosmopolitan. To give a very specific example, the special commission which was summoned to handle the 1871 outbreak and to decide whether quarantine of Kasımpaşa and Hasköy was necessary was chaired by an Ottoman medical official, Salih Efendi, and was composed of the physicians Bartoletti, Naranzi, Belisaire Bey, Davut Efendi, Sarian Bey and Saib Efendi – so, as you can see, there was a mix of physicians from European or Levantine backgrounds, Muslims, Armenians, and so on. Institutions like the Quarantine Council (Meclis-i Tahaffuz) began quite heavily dominated by Levantines or physicians attached to European embassies, but by 1885 many of these institutions were much more balanced between physicians with Ottoman citizenship and those with foreign citizenship. And, of course, within the hospitals of the city, there was a great mix of locally-trained and foreign physicians – although, as in many of the other more scientific fields in Istanbul during this time, French was the medium of medical practice rather than Turkish.

6- During the 1871 cholera outbreak in Istanbul the British embassy’s resident physician Edward Dalzel Dickson took the position against the British official view that cholera was contagious. Dickson was born in Tripoli, Lebanon and educated in Malta was a Levantine and perhaps because of this different ‘British’ background quite happy to confront the prevailing medical thinking at the time and history proved him right in his emphasis on quarantine etc. that could have saved more lives. Yet he was able to rise to the rank of chief physician of the British Embassy and later the Levant Herald paper turned on him. Was he only able to retain his position in the embassy institution that was ultimately answerable to the British Government by stepping back in his insistence that cholera was contagious when faced with the threat of consular prosecution?

It should be remembered that Dickson was really an institution himself in Istanbul by that point – he had been appointed by Great Britain as its representative to the Meclis-i Tahaffuz at the very start of the council, in 1840, and so he had occupied that role for over thirty years and was quite well-entrenched. And generally speaking, his position on the contagiousness of cholera was already more or less dominant amongst physicians in Britain itself, though the widespread adoption of zymotic theory; had he stated his position purely as a theoretical matter to a London-based medical journal, it probably would not have raised any attention at all. But at that point there was still not much experimentally to favor the zymotic theory of transmission over the endemic model supported by the British Foreign Office, and the most powerful imperial interest abroad – that is, the British government in India. In 1871 Dickson may have judged it too soon to really stake out a position against such a powerful interest within his own government. By the 1880s, though – even before the isolation of the cholera bacillus by Koch – absolute anti-contagionism had really become an extremely minority position scientifically, and the British government in India a real outlier in continuing to advocate for it – we might think of climate change denial as a contemporary counterpart, which is overwhelmingly rejected by the scientific community, but which has entrenched political constituencies in the United States, Canada, Australia and elsewhere. By 1881, Dickson may have felt on firmer scientific footing to oppose his own government – or else he might simply have ready to retire at that point, having been on the board for more than forty years, and have not really cared about whatever official consequences could result.

7- The British community in the Hasköy neighbourhood was particularly hit by the 1871 cholera outbreak by not following the quarantine regulations imposed on most other non-European areas. Do we know much about the nature and professions of this community on the Golden Horn from reports of the time?

Hasköy had historically been a predominantly Jewish neighborhood for several centuries at that point, and indeed alongside Balat was one of the major centers of Jewish cultural life in Istanbul; at the turn of the century, still about a quarter of the Jewish population of the city lived in Hasköy. The British community was vastly smaller, yet through institutions like the Levant Herald had a considerable influence within the city. Many of these British citizens worked for the humanitarian and evangelical institutions established within the neighborhood from the 1860s onwards – some with the support of Jewish organizations in Britain, others by evangelical Protestant associations intending to proselytize within the Empire. By the 1870s, there were a number of schools, chapels, hospitals, and other charitable institutions established by British organizations within Hasköy, and the cholera outbreak largely affected residents affiliated with these institutions; during the outbreak, as reported in the Levant Herald, the British residents tried to arrange relief efforts for the Jewish community of Hasköy, but there was also a great deal of profiteering and tension between the two communities.

8- The Levant Herald in this period seems to have been almost violently disruptive in its campaigns against quarantine regulations by the Ottoman Government imposed also on the British community. Do we know how much discomfort this caused the Ottoman Sultan and authorities as the newspaper was effectively the mouth-piece of the British Embassy with which it wished for friendly relations?

That’s a great question! I would have to check the archives, I think, to see what the reaction of the Ottoman censors and the Sultan himself was to the paper’s provocations during this time. Early in the following year, certainly, the paper found itself in serious legal trouble when it was sued by an Ottoman official for libel after it had criticized his conduct in a series of articles called “The Praetorians,” and in May of 1872 publication was suspended for three months. By the end of its suspension, the former editor, James McCoan, had sold his stake in the paper and given it to another British journalist, Edgar Whitaker. My friend Burhan Çağlar has written about these censorial twists and turns quite extensively – ultimately, the paper was something of a nuisance to the Ottoman government, but could also prove to be a useful tool and a kind of controlled opposition under certain circumstances, particularly during the reign of Abdülhamid II.

9- You talk of various European controlled systems in Istanbul such as the Galata health board which clearly made decisions independent of the Sultan on deciding on issues such as quarantine of ships in this important harbour. Do we know of the make-up of this and similar bodies and to what extent ‘locals’ had a say?

As I mentioned earlier, institutions like the Meclis-i Tahaffuz were initially quite heavily dominated by foreign-born and educated physicians – so when the Meclis-i Tahaffuz was founded, for instance, all of its members except the chairman, Mustafa Hıfzı Pasha, were foreign citizens. The proportion of Ottoman citizens on the council gradually increased, both by changing appointments and by an increase in the number of seats, so that by the end of the century there was a more equal distribution of officials within these institutions. The council was also bilingual, in Ottoman Turkish and French. However, there were still clear inequalities of power: the official language of the Gazette Medicale d’Orient, of course, remained only French, and Ottoman officials were compensated much less than their foreign-born counterparts. Likewise, there was a great deal of favoritism and nepotism, so that when a Greek citizen was head of the council, appointees tended to be Greeks, and so forth… to the point that when the novelist Ahmet Mithat Efendi held a position on the council, he actually appointed another Turkish writer to it, Cenap Şahabettin (who, to be fair, was also a practicing physician). So, there was a kind of continuous, low-level struggle over these institutions, and at times local Ottoman physicians had more or less say; at the same time, of course, they all professed commitment to universal humanitarian values and to a shared body of medical practice, which served to both obscure and (in times of crisis) highlight these structural inequalities.

Salih Efendi (the head of the quarantine commission and target of considerable criticism)
Questions by Craig Encer, May 2021