Costas Lapavitsas & Pinar Cakiroglu online lecture: ‘Ottoman industrial capitalism in Macedonia’, 25 November 2021 - flyer:
1- How long did it take you to research the subject of your book and was the chief source of information the Ottoman archives? Were you able to access information from descendants of these pioneer Greek industrialist families?
The gestation period of this book was quite long. Prof. Lapavitsas originates from Naousa and his family were involved in these processes, so he has long been familiar with people, places, local events, and other relevant information. He was encouraged to pursue the topic by Donald Quataert, one of the leading authorities in Ottoman economic history. In fact, he produced the first relevant academic paper by drawing mostly on Greek original sources and some authorities in Ottoman and Balkan studies.
More extensive and systematic research was, however, pursued by Dr Cakiroglu as part of her PhD, supervised by Prof. Lapavitsas. This research shed light on many unknown aspects of the story as it delved into the Ottoman sources for the first time. This required field work in Turkey and Greece using various archives, but most importantly uncovering and deciphering the documents from the Ottoman Archives in Istanbul. The documents had to be translated from Ottoman Turkish gradually to uncover a web of relations between families, communities, state authorities, and European production networks. This was the most troublesome but also the most exciting part.
As was already mentioned before, Prof. Lapavitsas is himself a descendant of one of the families involved and thus we had access to oral information and local knowledge. But it is worth mentioning one fortuitous event that helped us construct the analysis. A private letter was bought at a philately auction written by the first Christian mayor of Naoussa, who was a leading shayak trader. This was in fact the first available evidence of commercial correspondence from the 1870s which confirmed the broad framework that we had developed.
2- Salonica was clearly a major trade hub and the substantial Jewish community also had their industrial enterprises established in that city in the mid 19th century onwards. Was this Jewish centred industrialisation in a way in competition to the Mount Vermion region you concentrated in, or were the industrial sectors not overlapping, so the 2 regions evolved mostly independently of each other?
There was obviously economic competition between the members of the two communities. This did not begin with their members’ involvement in industrial production in the region but predated it through their commercial and financial activities. It was to some extent ‘normal’ considering how the religious minorities were divided within the Ottoman system. However, we can say that the competition intensified due to the discriminatory behaviour of central Ottoman power towards these communities throughout the nineteenth century mostly due to political worries about rising nationalism. The Jewish community of Salonica had far better connections with central Ottoman power. This was clearly shown in some of the Ottoman documents where the provincial Greek industrialists complained about concessions granted to the Jewish industrialists of Salonica but not to them.
3- Clearly the Ottoman authorities were nervous in providing permits to these budding Greek industrialists as the independent Kingdom of Greece was not too far away and so the relationship with this community was viewed through a somewhat suspicious prism. Could we argue that the Ottomans were also, at least later, pragmatists and couldn’t be too picky as to which community showed industrial entreprise as clearly the Ottomans were weakened by having such a late industrial revolution compared to Western countries?
The change came due to two main reasons though we should also say that the Ottoman authorities remained cautious towards Greek industrialists to the very end. The first was the Ottoman bankruptcy that became a seriously damaging event after the mid-1970s. Persistent financial difficulties made it clear that Ottoman industrialisation could no longer be carried forward simply through cooperation of the state with trusted groups, often based in Istanbul. This is the period that we begin to see the flowering of private industries. Second, the introduction of a new legal framework to sustain the emerging industries and to some extent dampening the discriminatory and arbitrary behaviour of the state. But we should keep in mind that the Ottoman state retained the power to appropriate and distribute economic rents to the very end.
4- Mount Vermion region has plenty of streams allowing for that power to be harnessed for many of the industrial processes. Do you think the location has other advantages that made it a centre for early industrialisation as opposed to other regions of Macedonia?
Unquestionably. We know from broader economic history research that water power can be a very efficient source of energy for the textile industry, in some respects better than internal combustion fed by fossil fuels. But it also requires significant initial investment and is obviously fixed to geographical place. Mount Vermion offered significant cost advantages in these regards. Another characteristic of the region was the availability of cheap labour, mostly women and children, and the lack of organised labour. This offered a major advantage compared to Salonica where the labour force was organised and more expensive. Cheap labour combined with the free water power from the streams were the biggest cost advantages of the region. Additionally, the arrival of the railways and the proximity to Salonica meant that the region had cheap transportation, easy access to internal and external markets, and more regular access to credit.
Greek cotton industrialists were able to exploit these advantages because of their extensive background in domestic manufacture and international trading of woollens. The international conditions if the 1860s and 1870s were particularly favourable as the US Civil War had created problems for Manchester, while the Ottoman state began to offer tax relief on equipment investment.
But it was not all advantages for the provincials. The spread and extraordinary density of ciftlik farms in the region prevented the emergence of modern capitalist agriculture, limited the domestic market in textiles, and failed to produce raw cotton inputs locally.
5- Clearly after 1912 with the incorporation of this region to the Kingdom of Greece new borders went up breaking the link to Constantinople as the potential buyer for these textile goods. Were the industrialists negatively affected by this or were they adaptable in finding new markets?
They were tremendously affected. From having access to the large domestic Ottoman market and to substantial exports they were suddenly limited to the Greek domestic market. In the international conditions of the 1930s exports were not really a viable large-scale alternative. But the industrialists adapted by developing connections with the Greek state and even developing capacity in Athens, including provision of cloth and uniforms for the army. It is interesting to note that several of them already used to do that for the Ottoman army and gendarmerie.
In the period after the Second World War there was a further flowering of textile production, and the region produced a very substantial proportion of high-quality European cotton yarn until the 1990s. Rapid decline set in at the end of the 1990s and today only one small enterprise remains, the last lineal descendant of an Ottoman tradition that began a hundred and fifty years ago.
6- For industrialisation to take place a number of factors need to come together. Was ‘Ottoman liberalisation’ in terms of Tanzimat reforms a factor or was the relatively remote location from the capital meant that had negligible benefits to entreprise. Did the local representatives of the Ottoman government understand the needs of the industrialists and provided them with such facilities such as travel passes, tax exemptions etc. or was this a bottle-neck in the process?
In some ways the region of Mount Vermion was ideally located, both close and far from the capital. It was close enough to be aware of developments and to benefit from progressive reforms. At the same time, it was far enough to solve emerging problems within the local community, where the Greek Orthodox çorbacı (rural elite layer) exercised power.
Interestingly, the Ottoman local authorities are almost absent in the documents. Local authorities were not, for instance, authorised to provide tax exemptions. For that one had to make an application directly to the central authorities. Prior to establishing a legal framework for exemptions, the local industrialists-to-be had to confront and negotiate with central authorities. This, obviously, reduced the pace and scale of industrialisation for the region but also for the Empire. Once private industries became more common and the regulation of the procedure for founding a factory became better established, things became easier for the industrialists.
7- The Ottoman authorities seem to have been very sensitive to the use and allocation of water resources by the industrialists. Does this to you suggest the Ottomans viewed that sector as crucial in terms of the well-being of all communities and have you come across any favouritism in terms of decisions regarding the various communities when deciding these allocations?
The Ottoman Empire was an agrarian empire and agriculture remained the dominant economic activity until the end. Therefore, the regulation of the water use was a very delicate issue. In one of the earliest applications to establish a factory in the region, this point was made very clear by the state. The authorities allowed the use of water as a source of power to run the mills, but also specified that this shall not affect the water use by others, including farmers.
In the same application, there is a very interesting part that tells a lot about the stance of the authorities. The applicants initially requested permission to establish a cotton and woollen factory but their request for woollen cloth production was declined on the grounds that the livelihood of many women in the region depended on the production of woollen cloth, obviously referring to a putting-out system of production. In yet another case where two industrialists-to-be of Naoussa got into conflict due to the use of water, the state declined both applications rather than taking sides. These examples clearly show that the priority of central Ottoman power was to avoid social conflict even at the cost of economic development. This does not mean there was no favouritism towards different communities, as shown in the case of Greek and Jewish communities of the Salonica region. However, over delicate issues, such as the use of water, the Ottoman priority was to avoid social unrest.
8- The European powers at the time had a heavy presence in the area dominating shipping and supplying a host of finished goods from their extensive empires. The Ottoman Government was also mostly in debt and its exports revenue was siphoned off by foreign bankers to pay back their huge loans. Do you think this situation was a major impediment for industrialisation across the empire? Do you think the few specialisation such as ‘aba’, ‘shayak’ were immune from this negative environment as foreigners weren’t able to provide traditional cloth for the Ottoman domestic market?
European industrial textile products were already dominant in the markets of late-comer countries, such as the Ottoman Empire, by the late nineteenth century. However, there were still various factors that worked to the benefit of the local industries. There was, for instance, a mismatch between traditional clothing customs, especially in the provinces, and European textile products. It was also difficult for European products to reach the smaller towns and the lower strata of the population.
Another factor was that many peasant families were still making their own clothes at home, so the local industries provided them with both yarn and woven fabric. ‘Aba’ is a coarse woollen fabric that was cheaper and more accessible for the low-income groups, and, hence, was still in demand. To strengthen home-made woollen clothes, the peasants also used cotton thread, which was also provided by the local industries. ‘Shayak’, on the other hand, was very high-quality woollen fabric that was exported from the Mount Version region throughout the 19th Century to Europe. The quality as well as price advantage was ensured by the availability of water sources, specifically waterfalls. Such local conditions gave natural protection to certain products in the face of European competition.
The siphoning of revenues by European powers was a problem mostly for products that were regulated by the European-controlled Ottoman Public Debt Administration, established to collect the Ottoman debt owed to European companies. Textile production was not directly affected by it.
9- Is there still more to research in this field? If you returned to the subject, how would you widen it?
In our work, we have shown that the primary capital accumulation of the industrialists of the Mount Version Region was achieved through commercial activities. This theoretically fits with the notion of the merchant becoming an industrial capitalist. Nevertheless, there was also the transformation of agriculture and agricultural relations in the same region, which is signalled by the intensity of ciftlik farms. This side-by-side development is an interesting point to widen the study especially in terms of theoretical discussions on the emergence of capitalism.
Another point that needs to be studied deeper is the financial side of the story. The development of finance and banking in relation to the development of industries would also reveal interesting points for telling the story of the capitalist transformation in the Ottoman Empire. Yet another study that focuses entirely on comparing the Jewish and Greek industrialists through their century long economic involvement and network has the potential to reveal much that is now obscure about the history of the late Ottoman Empire.