Anglo-Turkish Society

Dr Mike Hinton online lecture: ‘The cemetery at Haidar Pasha, Istanbul, with reference to those providing medical care during the Crimean War’, 3 June 2021 - flyer:

1- Was the Crimean War any worse than other wars of the 19th century concerning the prevalence of disease that clearly was a major killer of both soldiers and some of the civilians caring for their ailments/wounds?

When compared with other British campaigns prior World War 1 the Crimean War was not particularly exceptional from a medical point of view, though it proved challenging for several reasons: dysfunctional management systems in the army as a whole, especially during the early months; long lines of communication and the total reliance on shipping for supplies; the need to evacuate large numbers of sick and wounded during the first winter; epidemics of cholera in 1854 and 1855; and the appearance of scurvy and other medical conditions associated with malnutrition, and excessive hardship during the winter of 1854–55. The last two factors proved crucial in precipitating the catastrophic deterioration in the health of the troops; rather than a primary breakdown in hygiene or the presence of the cholera bacillus.

An underlying predicament was that the General Staff and their subordinates had to operate within a system which had been run down since 1815, and had not been reformed. It may have been sufficient to manage during peacetime but proved woefully inadequate for an army on campaign. Following the catastrophic events of the first winter systems of management were developed locally which were satisfactory by the standards of the day and which ultimately contributed to the Victory over Disease of 1856. [See Victory over Disease, pp. 315–21]

2- Were lessons learnt by the British Army establishment post this war and did the writings of Florence Nightingale have any bearing on this at the time?

Several commissions of enquiry, culminating in a Royal Commission, were appointed during and after the war. Florence Nightingale contributed privately to the Royal Commission. In the event the Commissioners concentrated more on future developments rather than making a retrospective assessment of what took place in the Crimea. The earlier commissions (hospital, sanitary, and supplies) provide useful historical information. It is unlikely that they had much of direct effect as the problems were resolved as a matter of course – and urgency – by all those involved in the supply and management of the army. [Victory over Disease, Chapter 9]

3- Were there ‘near front’ hospitals in the Crimea where the wounded and diseased could receive basic attention before presumably being shipped to Constantinople for proper treatment? Were the conditions in Crimea somewhat chaotic with it being near the front?

The early weeks or months of most campaigns tend to be chaotic and things do not go to plan!. General hospitals were opened in the Crimea including one in the camp near the front to where the wounded could be taken in the first instant. Another hospital well away from the main centres of inhabitation was used for convalescing wounded soldiers.

There were no suitable infrastructural facilities in the Crimea to cater for the needs of the army. This made it necessary to evacuate the sick and wounded to Turkey in the early months while hospital facilities were developed locally. Once matters stabilised the need to transport patients with a poor or hopeless prognosis became much less pressing as they could be looked after in the Crimea. This was associated with a welcome fall in mortality in the hospitals on the Bosphorus. [Victory over Disease, Chapter 7]

4- Did the lessons of looking after those with infectious disease learnt in the Scutari hospital quickly trickle down to the civilian hospital service post the war?

The germ theory was something for the future so the contemporary approach to dealing with the infectious disease does not resonate with 21st century clinical practice, especially as most people then believed that diseases were spread by bad air (miasma). Nevertheless, the military surgeons would have been well aware of the importance of basic hygienic measures, mosaic sanitation, the sourcing of a clean supply of water, and the provision of an adequate diet, clothing, and shelter since these principles had been recognized in the Napoleonic Wars, or even earlier. Seemingly, in later years Florence Nightingale was slow to accept the germ theory when it was promulgated so it is unlikely that she would have had any more advanced ideas on disease control than the army medical officers.

5- Is Florence Nightingale as important as we see her today in that role of promotion of good hygiene and using statistics to prove those results?

The contribution of talented and well-connected Florence Nightingale and the suitably qualified government sponsored sanitary commissioners have been overstated as the problems at Scutari merely reflected the situation at the front. It was there were the problems were overcome, and as things improved in the Crimea so they did at Scutari. [Victory over Disease, Chapter 7] Florence Nightingale’s greatest achievements were yet to come.

6- Was Scutari only one of the hubs of hospitals with adjoining cemetery created during the Crimean War by the British, extending to Smyrna, Malta etc. and point to the huge challenges of caring for the sick and wounded from a vicious war whose casualty load was hard to bear locally?

The regiment was the principal unit in the army and the regimental hospital provided primary health care when stationary. Obviously, things were different while on campaign when an increase in the number of sick and wounded could be expected; as it did spectacularly during the first six months after landing in the Crimea. General hospitals employing staff rather than regimental surgeons provided extra capacity. Nine general hospitals were utilized at various times; three were in the Crimea and those on the Bosphorus, including the Barrack Hospital where Florence Nightingale was based. The others were located in Bulgaria, Abydos, Smyrna, and Renkioi. [Victory over Disease, pp. 97–131]

7- The Crimean war cemetery in the Crimea has all been effectively destroyed over the years as the Commonwealth Graves Commission doesn't have jurisdiction there. Was that because the CWGC only deals with WWI & WWII burials chiefly or point the problematic diplomatic history of Britain with Russia?

There were approximately 130 British cemeteries in the Crimea at the end of the war. Problems of their maintenance became an issue in the years that followed. In the 1880s the surviving monuments, but not the remains, were relocated at the principal cemetery on Cathcart’s Hill. This cemetery was being tended – with no little difficulty – up to beginning of World War 2 when it was destroyed during the severe fighting around Sevastopol. The cemetery at Haidar Pasha on the Bosphorus was opened in 1854. It was subsequently used for civilian burials, and later for casualties of both world wars. The whole property is now under the care of the CWGC. [Additional information on cemeteries can be found in Hinton, M., ‘A glimpse of the Haidar Pasha cemetery: 1910 and a century on’, The War Correspondent (Journal of the Crimean War Society), 37:2 (2020), 35–40; Hinton, M., ‘A sad end for a fine memorial: the Royal Engineers’ monument erected on Cathcart’s Hill commemorating those who died during the Crimean War’, Royal Engineers Journal, 134:1 (2020), 69–74; and Hinton, M., ‘Memorials to Royal Artillery personnel who died in the Crimea and Turkey, 1854–1856’, The Journal of the Royal Artillery, 150:1 (2021), 61–7]

8- I also have a distant ancestor 6 generations removed who served in the Crimea, and according to family legend he had to walk across northern France to reach transport on the Rhine and later another walk to the Danube as there was a shortage of shipping to take his unit across the Mediterranean route. He survived and on the return walk journey the young toll-bridge lady in Northern France he had promised to marry if he survived was clearly equally smitten to accept that elopement. Do you think this ‘walking across Europe’ for the ‘Irish contingents’ is plausible or does it point to a ‘pecking order’ within the various British regiments at the time?

Virtually all the troops and supplies were conveyed to the East by sea. Officers, and official documents, were able to travel across land from the channel ports to the south of France using rail and river transport. It was also possible to get to the Black Sea by rail and river via Germany and Austria, and then down the Danube. It may have been used by senior military and civilian personnel but not the ordinary soldier.

Some of the issues raised by these questions are covered in detail in Hinton, M., Victory over Disease: Resolving the Medical Crisis in the Crimean War, 1854–1856, (Warwick: Helion, 2019).

Questions by Craig Encer, August 2021