Anglo-Turkish Society

Prof Dina Danon online lecture: ‘Modernity in the Eastern Sephardi Diaspora: The Jews of Late Ottoman Izmir’, 24 February 2022 - flyer:

1- In 1899 the death of the influential chief Rabbi of Izmir Abraham Palacci was clearly a crisis moment for the Jewish community in the city. There seems to have been socio-economic interest groups who put their own pressure for the next Rabbi to be sympathetic to their interests, in particular to the management of the local Kosher meat industry and the sales tax which generated the overwhelming income for the community. Does this suggest there was corruption inherent with this system whereby portions of this tax ended in the pockets of the chief players in this industry and perhaps also the Rabbi?

The tax on kosher meat – the gabela - was the backbone of the community’s budget. Without the revenue it generated, the community would not have been able to sustain its schools, charities, synagogues, cemetery, etc. At the same, because it was a sales tax, it was essentially regressive and burdened poorer consumers much more heavily than others. And because poverty was widespread in the community, the meat tax became a perennial source of class conflict. There were various groups involved in the kosher meat industry – the slaughterers of cattle, the sellers of meat in the marketplace, and tax farmers who bought the tax outright and levied it later on, mirroring the traditional Ottoman system of iltizam. While the system itself wasn’t structurally corrupt, the sheer complexity of the system and variety of stakeholders in it made it vulnerable to corruption. As for chief rabbis, they were often seen as bulwarks against the injustices of the gabela tax and frequently spoke out in favor of reforming or removing the tax entirely.

2- Clearly this tax system debate in the community in 1899 was done in the back-drop of a rapidly changing city and its Jewish minority gradually losing its socio-economic status in its evolution to a major export port. Do you think the Jewish community was too inward looking and its links to overseas ports such as in Iberia were now a distant memory and they found it had to compete with local Greek entrepreneurs who had better networking and perhaps language abilities?

The deterioration of the socioeconomic position of Izmir’s Jewish community in the modern age was not a result of an “inward looking” profile but rather a constellation of global and local factors. Like other groups across the Empire as well as European merchants, Jews came to Izmir in the early 17th century to participate in its early modern economic boom. European Levant companies relied on Jews to help them navigate the world of Ottoman commerce, and they served largely as intermediaries, working as brokers, translators, agents, and moneylenders. Once the state began to take an interest in the port’s success, Jews also entered into customs collections and were heavily represented in that field. By the nineteenth century, however, the landscape had changed for Izmir’s Jewish community. Challenges to the state’s authority on the part of powerful local clans had wrested away local and regional tax collection, while European merchants had become more emboldened to circumvent Ottoman officialdom entirely, which ultimately made Jewish knowledge of state systems less valuable. Crucially, the nature of the port itself shifted – Izmir became less of a transit point for goods produced further east and more of a center for the export of raw materials from its own hinterland. It was Izmir’s Greeks who were notably well-positioned in this new landscape, as they functioned ably on both the Anatolian production side as well as the export side of the market. Continuous renegotiation of European capitulations further bolstered the position of Christian merchants. By the late imperial period, it was Izmir’s Greeks, whether Ottoman or Hellenes, who predominated across trade on the international, regional, and local scales. Alongside them, of course, were significant numbers of Levantine merchants as well as a small but prosperous Armenian community as well.

3- Countries in Eastern Europe such as Russia had a tax known as the korobka, was a tax paid only by Jews for each animal slaughtered in accordance with the kashrut rules and for each pound of this meat sold. It was part of the Russian Jewish ‘basket tax’ or ‘box tax’. Clearly this was a discriminatory and burdensome tax. Was the tax in Ottoman lands quite unlike this system, where income was collected and then distributed solely by the community? Did the Jews have to pay any special taxes such as the jizya the Christian minorities had to pay and was there a system where the community clubbed together to pay such taxes to the state where individuals were in poverty?

While both the gabela and korobka were taxes on kosher meat, ultimately they were quite different from each other. The gabela was a tax levied completely internally by the Jewish community – it was not required or implemented by the state. Its revenue was meant to cover expenses internal to the Jewish community – schools, charities, etc. Ottoman Jews, just like Ottoman Christians, did pay the jizya poll tax, and in the later Tanzimat era, the bedel-i askeri military exemption tax. While the mechanics of taxation were sometimes fluid, taxes such as the jizya were imposed on the community as a whole, which in turn managed the levy internally upon individuals. As such, those who were impoverished were typically exempted.

4- Through the 19th century European Jews had to contend with the homogenising pressures to assimilate by the nation states, you characterise as the ‘tension between the universal and particular’. How do you define these notions of universal and particular; are they rooted in the difficulties of reconciling the overall sense of global Jewishness versus the internal and external local pressures to ‘fit in’? Clearly the Ottoman legal and social environment was totally different as the ‘millet’ system reinforced religious separation. In your opinion was there a different and softer route for the community to feel assimilation pressure through rising national and liberal consciousness with the Tanzimat reforms?

The tension between the “universal” and the “particular” is one of the big motifs of modern Jewish history in the West. Due to the homogenizing pressures embedded in both European nation-states and empires alike, Jews were often faced with the notion that their religious, ethnic, cultural difference was somehow incompatible with the modern age. The Ottoman Empire functioned quite differently. Its approach to Islamic law as well as its profound cultural and religious diversity cultivated a social fabric that was not merely tolerant of difference but actually predicated upon it. For Jews, this legitimation of difference remained the case through efforts to promote shared forms of belonging such as the Ottomanism of the Tanzimat Reform era or the constitutional fervor of the Young Turks.

5- Clearly there was a significant underclass Jewish population with a large number of beggars from that community in Izmir. In 1878 the Jewish community of the city established the ‘Stewards of Charity Society’ to alleviate this poverty. You were able to access the ‘Defter de reklamos Gabbae Sedaka’, recording the weekly investigations into the individual circumstances of the beggars, giving you an insight to how poverty was lived and experienced in this Jewish community at the time. Did these entries apportion any blame to this poverty or were they merely factual entries to the various beggars’ levels of deprivation?

While the entries themselves do not expressly blame petitioners for their poverty, one can discern shifting attitudes to poverty in the decisions administrators made in individual cases. The very fact that claims were investigated at all suggests that administrators were grappling with new notions of “deservedness.” The directing of those perceived to be able-bodied to work evidences a deepening encounter with attitudes that equated poverty with laziness, disorder, and sin.

6- The 1907 ‘Talmud Tora’ Charity Ball in aid of a school for improvished Jewish children listed in its programme the honorary committee high ranking members of the Ottoman, Greek and Levantine communities. Would you characterise the cultural climate in Izmir at the time lacking any sort of anti-Semitism that was rife in so many other regions of the world at the time?

Certainly, late Ottoman Izmir did not see the antisemitism that characterized the Jewish experience in western Europe (on the level of discourse) or in eastern Europe (in the form of violent pogroms) in the same period. However, it would be wrong to presume it was completely absent from the landscape. With the city and region’s sizeable Greek population, old Christian anti-Jewish attitudes manifested themselves periodically, most notably in the form of blood libels. Additionally, in the age of irridentist nationalisms, Jewish loyalty to the Ottoman state made the community vulnerable to discrimination and violence on the part of local Greeks.

7- Your own ancestry also hails from Izmir. How far back can you take that line and do you know what sort of professions they led?

My ancestry on my paternal side hails from Izmir, although sadly I have not been able to trace back beyond a couple of generations. One branch of the family was from Manisa and migrated to Izmir, while others were originally from Istanbul. My great-grandfather was a shop-keeper who sold dried fruit and nuts, which is very characteristic of the socio-economic profile of the larger community. My grandparents were both born in Izmir as were some of my aunts.

8- Izmir wasn’t the only Ottoman city with a significant Jewish population. If you decided in the future to widen your investigation to another region which Jewish community would you like to focus on?

From the perspective of available sources, Izmir is unique in the eastern Sephardi diaspora in the way its vast communal archive has been preserved. While we lack these sources for other communities, I still hope to draw on the history of other communities such as Salonica and Istanbul by studying other sources, such as the region’s vibrant Ladino press.

Questions by Craig Encer, May 2022