Jane Hathaway online lecture: ‘The Sultan’s Eunuch: The Chief Harem Eunuch as Shaper of the Ottoman Empire’, 9 September 2021 - flyer:
1- When did you first start researching the history of eunuchs in the Ottoman Empire and did the book project evolve naturally from that when you went deeper?
When I was conducting research for my dissertation on the military-administrative households of Ottoman Egypt, I stumbled across the Chief Harem Eunuch, who, I soon realized, had an immense amount of influence in Egypt because of the imperial pious foundations for Mecca and Medina (Evkafü’l-Haremeyn). Specific Egyptian villages supplied the grain that was transported to the Holy Cities with the hajj caravan every year, and since the Chief Eunuch supervised revenue collection for the endowments empire-wide, he had a whole network of connections with Egypt’s grandees, who competed for the tax farms of these villages. One chapter of my first book, The Politics of Households in Ottoman Egypt: The Rise of the Qazdağlıs (Cambridge, 1997), dealt with the Chief Harem Eunuch’s role in Ottoman Egypt’s political culture. Around the time I published that book, I also published several articles on various features of the Chief Eunuch’s relationship to Egypt. I thought that eventually, I would write a book on the office of Chief Eunuch with an empire-wide purview. This turned out to be The Chief Eunuch of the Ottoman Harem.
2- Do we know much if anything on the ethnicity and organisation of the slave raiders that provided the boys to be castrated to become potential eunuchs?
I am not an expert on the East African slave trade, but I believe that some of the traders came from the Muslim kingdoms on the Red Sea coast of the Horn of Africa, what are now Eritrea and Somalia. The Red Sea ports in this region were key shipment points for future eunuchs across the Red Sea to the Hijaz. Otherwise, the identity of the raiders and traders is rather vague. I think there were merchants in parts of Ethiopia and Sudan who took advantage of civil wars and similar upheavals to seize young boys. The caravan trade through Sudan was well-organized, and an organized cadre of traders took part in the trade in slaves, and in ivory and other luxury goods, through the Sudan to Egypt every year. I discuss some of this in chapter 2 of The Chief Eunuch, but there are more authoritative books dealing with this trade in detail. I could mention the following:
R.W. Beachey, The Slave Trade of Eastern Africa (New York: Barnes and Noble; London: Rex Collings, 1976)
Humphrey Fisher, Slavery in the History of Muslim Black Africa (New York: New York University Press, 2001)
Alice Moore-Harell, “Economic and Political Aspects of the Slave Trade in Ethiopia and the Sudan in the
Second Half of the Nineteenth Century,” International Journal of African Historical Studies 32, 2 (1999): 407-21
Terence Walz, Trade between Egypt and Bilād as-Sudān, 1700-1820 (Cairo: IFAO, 1978) _____, ed., Race and Slavery in the Middle East: Histories of Trans-Saharan Africans in Nineteenth-Century Egypt, Sudan, and the Ottoman Mediterranean (Cairo: American University in Cairo Press, 2010)
John R. Willis, ed., Slaves and Slavery in Muslim Africa, 2 vols. (London and Totowa, NJ: Frank Cass, 1985)
3- Sultan Murad III (r. 1574–95) inaugurated the post of Chief Harem Eunuch when he transferred supervision of the imperial pious foundations for the Muslim holy cities of Mecca and Medina to the head of the harem eunuchs from the head of the white eunuchs who patrolled the third court of Topkapı Palace, where the sultan had his privy chamber. Clearly this was a seismic shift in the power and influence of the Chief Eunuchs from then onwards. What do you think was the Sultan's motivation in this change?
I see two main factors here: (1) Murad’s attachment to the harem, where he spent most of his private time, and (2) his closeness to Habeshi Mehmed Agha, the head of the harem eunuchs for most of his reign. He was also close to the head of the white eunuchs (Gazanfer Agha), but Habeshi Mehmed was older and may have been a sort of paternal figure. He was also immensely wealthy and influential, with strong ties to Egypt, a key consideration where supervision of the Evkafü’l-Haremeyn was concerned.
4- Clearly under many Sultans there were factions and intrigue and plots within the inner sanctum of the Ottoman palace, with competing forces of white and black eunuchs, the grandvezir and Sultan’s mother (Valide), Sultan’s first consort (Haseki), and the mother of his first-born son often at loggerheads and the Chief Eunuch having to navigate this minefield and hoping to back the side that was in the ascendant in the future. Clearly some backed the losing side. Were some of the Chief Eunuch executed for this, and if so, was this done publicly or discreetly?
As you would expect, most of the executions and murders occurred during the 17th-century crisis, and usually during military rebellions that engulfed the palace. In 1603, the Kapı-Ağası (“chief white eunuch”) Gazanfer Agha and the Chief Harem Eunuch, his ally Osman Agha, were both murdered in the second court of Topkapı, right in front of the sultan’s audience chamber, by a mob of angry soldiers, so that, to quote the famous polymath Katib Çelebi, their two heads rolled to the door of the audience chamber “like a black bead and a white bead.” A similarly quasi-public execution occurred during the “Plane Tree Incident” (Çınar Vakası) of 1656, when the Chief Harem Eunuch Behram Agha, along with the Kapı-Ağası and a number of other officials, were killed by mutinous soldiers and their corpses hung from a plane tree in Istanbul’s hippodrome. More commonly, a Chief Eunuch who ran afoul of the sultan, the grand vizier, or some other influential official would be exiled to an Aegean island, such as Lemnos, then discreetly strangled later.
5- Were the ‘white eunuchs’ (KapıAğası and his entourage) of lower status to the ‘black eunuchs’ as the former were responsible for controlling ‘the Gate of Felicity’ that separated the Outer Court (Birûn, where state affairs were conducted), from the Inner Court (Enderûn) and the Sultan’s private apartments in the Topkapi Palace? Still important functions but he had nothing to do with the harem and its vital role of producing plenty of potential male heirs. Do we know the regional / ethnic origin of where these eunuchs were ‘farmed’ from and did they undergo a similar schooling / training as their African counterparts?
For the first 120 years or so after Topkapı’s construction, ca. 1458, the white, or Third Court, eunuchs were of higher status than the African harem eunuchs since the sultan, when he was in the palace, spent most of his time in his privy chamber in the Third Court. This is why the Kapı-Ağası, or Chief Threshold Eunuch, was officially the head of the imperial household. However, when Murad III moved into the harem and appointed Habeshi Mehmed Agha Chief Harem Eunuch, the Third Court eunuchs’ superior status came under threat. We can see the two corps of eunuchs and their leaders jockeying for position in the decades that followed. This process resulted in curious alliances such as that between the powerful KapıAğası Gazanfer Agha and the Chief Harem Eunuch Osman Agha (the two who were killed in the 1603 military revolt), both in turn allies of Murad III’s favorite concubine Safiye Sultan. (Given that Gazanfer and other high-ranking Third Court eunuchs participated in palace factions led by imperial women such as Safiye, it is not entirely accurate to say that they had nothing to do with the harem. In addition, the Chief Harem Eunuch tried to cultivate his own allies among the Third Court eunuchs and among the non-eunuch officials of the sultan’s privy chamber). The image I showed of the enthronement of Osman II, with the two corps of eunuchs ranged on either side of the painting and the new sultan’s throne just right of center, on the “harem” side of the painting, illustrates the competition between the two corps of eunuchs.
As I noted in my presentation, most of the Third Court eunuchs seem to have come from the Balkans, the Aegean islands, and Venice before the late seventeenth century. Gazanfer Agha was Venetian and belonged to an important Venetian palace faction led by Safiye Sultan, who was a “culturally Venetian” Albanian. This alliance has been analyzed by Maria Pia Pedani in a well-known article (“Safiye’s Household and Venetian Diplomacy,” Turcica 32 (2000): 9-32). Beginning in the later seventeenth century, more and more Third Court eunuchs came from the Caucasus, above all Georgia.
The Third Court eunuchs were educated in the palace pages’ school in the Third Court of Topkapı, and in fact, they comprised many of the pages to whom the school’s sobriquet refers. Their education was, so far as we know, virtually identical to that of the harem eunuchs, focused on the Qur’an, Hanafi exegesis and law, Arabic grammar, Ottoman history, and related subjects.
6- The chief eunuch by controlling the foundations of Mecca and Medina effectively could presumably divert or cream off a steady income. Did the Ottoman palace system have over-seeing auditors or was corruption easy to get away with?
There were certainly corrupt Chief Eunuchs, but I am not sure that the Chief Eunuch needed to “cream off” his income from the imperial pious foundations. As I noted in the presentation, he could found personal vakıfs within the overall framework of the imperial foundations, and he received the surplus revenue (known as faiz, the word used in modern Turkish for “interest,” as in interest on a checking account). He also received a salary and, after deposition, a stipend for use in retirement/exile.
7- Clearly many chief eunuchs were able to retire rich, if allowed, of course, and live comfortably in their discreetly earlier created households together with their complements of slaves in Cairo or elsewhere. Did you come across any chief eunuchs who adopted local children to pass on their inheritance, or make contact with their blood relatives / villages to ensure they also benefited?
This kind of “retirement” was possible only in Cairo, and in Medina once the practice was established of appointing deposed Chief Harem Eunuchs to the office of head of the eunuchs who guarded the Prophet Muhammad’s tomb. There is no record of retired eunuchs “adopting” local children, although the chiefs of the Tomb Eunuchs did supposedly take wives who were originally enslaved East Africans. (Whether these wives were strictly ceremonial is not known). On the other hand, the many Qur’an schools that the (acting) Chief Eunuchs founded in Cairo and other locales were usually designed to educate orphan boys, so in that sense we could say that the Chief Eunuch “adopted” local children inasmuch as he provided for their education.
African eunuchs did not, to the best of our knowledge, retain any contact with their birthplaces or with family members – in marked contrast to devşirme recruits and even Third Court eunuchs such as Gazanfer Agha, who, as Pedani points out, brought several family members to Topkapı. The one harem eunuch who is known to have tried to locate his family is Nadir Agha in the early twentieth century, as I explained in the presentation.
8- Ottoman Sultans were not the only ones to have harems in the Ottoman world. Was it customary for the elite of the Ottoman administration to have their own harems (whether just female relations or concubines) to also be guarded by African-origin eunuchs?
Yes, Ottoman officials throughout the empire, as well as wealthy merchants and scholars, had harems populated by their wives, unmarried daughters, and concubines (if any). Such a harem would normally occupy a separate part of the residence. Unlike the imperial harem, however, these domestic harems were not designed to reproduce a dynasty, so they were much smaller. Typically, a single East African eunuch, perhaps with one or two assistants, would guard such a harem.
9- By the early eighteenth century, after a series of crises, the Ottoman economy grew again as trade with western Europe, and France in particular, boomed. The Chief Harem Eunuchs of the era directly encouraged this trade by serving as conduits for European luxury goods to the women of the harem. El-Hajj Beshir Agha (term 1717– 46), the longest-serving and most powerful Chief Eunuch in Ottoman history, presided over elaborate night-time garden parties at which luxurious European baubles were conspicuously consumed. Do you think this opening up could be seen as the first tentative steps in the later reform movements a century later or do you think the world of the harem had very little bearing to the wider Ottoman world?
This opening up to peaceful relations with Europe actually goes back farther, to the late seventeenth century – and in the case of France, to the sixteenth century, when Süleyman I signed a treaty of friendship with the king of France. However, the notion that diplomacy was a key means of engaging with the European powers gained serious traction within the Ottoman central administration during the eighteenth century, so that the reisü’l-küttab, or “chief scribe,” had become a proto-foreign minister by the middle of the century. The Chief Harem Eunuch’s main contribution to this sort of peaceful engagement may have been channeling French and Italian luxury goods to the harem women. On the other hand, el-Hajj Beshir Agha had a confrontation with the famous reisü’l-küttab and future grand vizier Raghib Mehmed Pasha in the early 1740s, when the latter wanted to end a conflict with the Iranian ruler Nadir Shah by recognizing Twelver Shi‘ism as a fifth Sunni “Jafari madhhab.” El-Hajj Beshir vehemently rejected this proposal, scuttling the negotiations.
More broadly, the “counsel for sultans” literature sometimes known as “decline literature”, in which an official or scholar points out ways for the sultan to correct the direction of the empire, can also be seen as the root of the late eighteenth-century reforms and perhaps even of the Tanzimat. “Decline literature” goes back to the 1540s, during Süleyman I’s reign, even though this was supposedly the high point of the Ottoman Empire.
10- The Chief Harem Eunuch’s influence extended beyond palace politics and through his personal pious endowments, he founded mosques, madrasas, Qurʾān schools, and libraries throughout the empire that had a profound effect on Ottoman religious and intellectual life. In frontier provinces such as what are now Bulgaria and Romania, these foundations reinforced the presence of the Ottoman brand of Sunni Islam of the Hanafi legal rite, not least by supplying manuscripts of canonical works of Hanafi law and theology. Did this go in opposition to the strong Bektashi tradition as practiced by the Janissaries, and do we see friction between these two authorities as they competed in similar geographies?
The Hanafi madhhab is a legal rite; thus, it is not directly comparable to the Bektashi Sufi order in terms of its place in society. Most Bektashis adhered to the Hanafi madhhab when it came to legal practice. On the other hand, the harem eunuchs and many other Ottoman officials patronized more “orthodox” Sufi orders, notably the Halvetis and the Naqshbandis. (The Chief Harem Eunuchs seem not to have belonged to the Mevlevi order, which was, however, closely associated with the Ottoman court and the sultan). I think the Bektashi order was closely associated with the Janissaries and also with certain populations of artisans and peasants in particular parts of the Balkans and Anatolia. It was not really associated with the court and Ottoman officialdom, and thus did not compete in the same sphere with the Sufi orders patronized by the Chief Eunuch and similar officials.
11- Was the Chief Eunuch also responsible for overseeing the early education of the young princes, thus acting as an important early influence on future Sultans?
Yes, as I pointed out in the presentation, the Chief Eunuch oversaw the princes’ initial schooling in a schoolroom right outside the Chief Eunuch’s apartments in Topkapı Palace. A prince’s tutor, or hoca, was usually chosen by the prince’s mother in consultation with the Chief Eunuch. When the prince reached his late teens, he moved out of the harem proper, either to govern an Anatolian province or, after 1595, to a suite of rooms toward the rear of the harem complex.
12- Why do you think the Saudi Wahhabi authorities retained the institution of the tomb eunuchs in Medina when they took over the holy cities in the 1920s till slavery was abolished in 1962?
This is a surprising development, particularly when we consider that when the Wahhabi-Saudi alliance first occupied Mecca and Medina in the early years of the nineteenth century, they expelled the Tomb Eunuchs and sent them to Egypt. Possibly the retention of the institution was part of Abdulaziz ibn Saud’s decision, at British urging, to temper the Wahhabi-ization of the Holy Cities. Thus, he allowed religious officials in Mecca and Medina to follow other madhhabs besides the Saudi-approved Hanbali madhhab, and he refrained from razing the Prophet’s tomb. I would guess that other constituencies prevailed on him to continue the institution of Tomb Eunuchs. The eunuchs who were in place at the time of the Saudi conquest may have may an appeal to him.
13- You are currently working on the Cairo Geniza, a collection of some 400,000 Jewish manuscript fragments and administrative documents that were found in the genizah or storeroom of the Ben Ezra Synagogue in Fustat, or Old Cairo, Egypt. These manuscripts outline a 1,000-year continuum (870 CE to 19th century) of Jewish, MiddleEastern and North African history and comprise the largest and most diverse collection of medieval and early modern manuscripts in the world. Would you compare this collection to the Rosetta stone in that it opens up a huge window of research?
The Rosetta Stone is perhaps not the appropriate analogy since the Rosetta Stone was one text in several different ancient Egyptian languages and thus held the key to deciphering ancient Egyptian hieroglyphics. The Geniza, as the late S.D. Goitein and earlier scholars demonstrated, is an extraordinary source for the history of Jewish thought and practice, on one hand, and for Jewish and broader Middle Eastern socio-economic history, on the other. What I am studying is (a tiny part of) the Ottoman-era corpus of documents from the Geniza, which are virtually unstudied compared to the much larger medieval corpus (roughly 330,000 of the roughly 400,000 documents are from the 10th-early 13th centuries). The Ottoman-era material can shed light on a variety of subjects, notably how Egypt was incorporated into the Ottoman Empire, trade patterns in the Ottoman period, how converts from Judaism to Islam related to their former community, and material culture and popular culture in Egypt and vicinity during the Ottoman era.